August’s lineup felt like three different experiments pulled from three different moods: a candy-coated sugar rush, an herby Italian comfort mash-up, and a tropical burger that swung big. The results weren’t uniform, but they were memorable, each one asking you to lean into the fun and see how far it could go.
Nutty By Nature ($16.00)
Peanut butter frappe with a Reese’s peanut butter ice cream bar, Nutty Buddy, Funny Bones, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cereal, and Reese’s Pieces
This was the undisputed star of the month. Nutty By Nature nailed the frappe formula, layering every peanut butter-lover’s dream into one glass. The base was creamy and rich without tipping into cloying, and the mix of toppings actually worked together instead of just piling on. The Reese’s bar brought indulgence, the Nutty Buddy gave crunch, and the cereal and candies turned it into a playful spectacle. It was excessive in all the right ways—one of the best frappes to ever hit their menu.
Presto Pesto ($13.00)
Fries, basil pesto, mozzarella, parmesan, marinara drizzle, fresh basil
The flavors were there: bright basil, aromatic pesto, gooey cheese, and a tangy marinara drizzle that tied it all together. The issue was the base. Fries just can’t handle that much sauce, and before long the whole thing collapsed into sogginess. The idea itself is strong, but it needs a sturdier vessel. Imagine arancini balls smothered in pesto instead—suddenly, you’ve got something truly special. As it was, this dish started with promise but faded fast.
Tropic Like It’s Hot ($17.50)
Burger, fried plantains, fresh mango pico de gallo, chipotle mayo, cilantro cream, shredded lettuce
This burger managed to balance a lot of moving parts and make it work. The fried plantains added a starchy sweetness, the mango pico brought brightness, and the chipotle mayo with cilantro cream kept heat and cool in harmony. The patty didn’t get lost, either—it all came together in a way that felt vibrant, messy, and worth the effort. Creative, bold, and ultimately satisfying.
Final Thoughts
August delivered a lineup that was eclectic but far from forgettable. Nutty By Nature stood tall as a near-perfect frappe, easily the highlight of the month. Presto Pesto carried great flavors but fell apart in execution, begging for a better format. Tropic Like It’s Hot brought an inventive twist that pushed the burger in new, refreshing directions. Not everything hit its mark, but the month proved that Boston Burger Company is still willing to take chances—and when they land, the results can be outstanding.